Monday, August 4, 2008

Selecting The Right Trainer



SELECTING THE RIGHT TRAINER

Finding the right trainer may seem like an intimidating task. This is the most important decision you will make concerning your riding. Beginning lessons are of the utmost importance. Simply put, without the proper basic training, your riding may be sufficient to get you going, but you will always struggle with certain aspects of riding. So how do you find the ideal trainer for you? The only way is to do the groundwork.

Visit barns in your area and ask to watch different trainers give a lesson... Talk to the trainers you feel comfortable with. Ask them their philosophy of riding and training students. This will give you a clue what to expect from them. If they seem anxious to put you in their lesson program and get you to shows, this is not the viewpoint you are looking for at this stage. Another thing to think about when you choose a trainer: You should be up front with the trainer and let them know that you are visiting different barns and taking lessons elsewhere, to see where you fit in best. This way they will not be offended if you decide not to train with them. Any trainer will take a student on, but are reluctant to let them go. Of course, egos and pocketbooks are always involved. Remember, the horse community is very small and you are bound to see the same groups of people occasionally, at shows or clinics etc., so always use tact when you decide to leave one trainer for another.

The Basics

Trainers should be willing to teach the basics and should be concerned with your safety and the horses’. At times, I feel the trainer’s ego may get in the way of their compassion and common sense. Regrettably, it is also about decisions based on making money, sometimes at the cost of their horses and clients. A good trainer will take the time to answer all of your questions. You need someone who allows you to take as much time as you require learning the basics. Teaching you how to groom, tack up, and lead a horse properly is a good foundation. When time comes to ride, take it slow, do mounting lessons, and walk on the lunge, this will give you a feel for the horse’s movement, your own balance and the proper position. It is also a chance to be acclimated to the new atmosphere. This may all sound too easy, but there are important safety issues to learn here. When you are able to accomplish these things safely at the walk, only then is it permissible to go on to the trot and eventually the canter. The key is not to let anyone rush you into uncomfortable situations sooner than you feel ready. Any trainer who does not want to take the time to teach the basics, more than likely is not the one for you.

Of course, you will also want to see the types of lesson horses available for beginner lessons. Obviously, you want an older experienced school horse that has, ‘been there, done that’. In one of my earliest lessons, I was put on a thoroughbred straight off the racetrack; my trainer assured me it was safe. Not knowing any better, I did it. Suffice it to say, it was quite a ride, but it was not a positive experience. A situation like that does not do much for your confidence. I fell off in another lesson on the same horse, as I was “teaching” him to jump cross rails: he stopped; I went straight over his head and landed on my back. The up side was that one of us made it to the other side of the jump. That was my first fall ever… lots of fun. This was a case of being pushed along to fast for my abilities.

Patience and Respect

Also, in your lessons if you find that your trainer is belittling you or losing their patience, it is not out of the question to stop and inform them that you don‘t appreciate being at the receiving end of a tirade. Never lose your temper. There are tactful ways to handle this situation. I have seen many trainers abuse their students to the point of a student being in tears or so nervous they just continue making mistakes. Trainer abuse is always unacceptable. If a trainer cannot act in a professional manner, they should not be schooling you. Many people are actually fearful of speaking up and so they just go on taking the mistreatment directed at them or their horse. I am here to tell you there is absolutely no reason you have to put up with this kind of behavior. Remember, you are a client who is actually paying good money for these lessons. When was the last time you went into a shop for a service and paid money to be abused? You would not take it there, so why would you take it from someone giving you a riding lesson? I would suggest talking to the trainer in a calm manner, in private, and explaining to him/her that they are making you feel less confident, and more nervous. You should both be able to come to an agreement about your training preferences. If you don‘t get the response you want, then you know what to do.

Qualifications

Ask what qualifications the trainer has, you will come across many trainers who have at sometime in their career won a few blue ribbons or maybe a prestigious award, which more than likely means something only to them. It is usually not relevant and some will even boost themselves a little by giving the illusion that they are at the top of their game. The longer ago their accomplishment was the more they remember what a great rider they are. A trainer may have been or still is a good rider, but not all are good instructors. Next, we have the young crowd who has decided this is the life for them. They get to hang around the barn all day, give up-down lessons to pony kids and beginners, and ride absentee boarder’s horses and feel like they are relevant in the horse world - when they probably should not be giving lessons to a dog. Anybody can don the trainers cap and give lessons to whomever they wish. There is such a disregard for safety here; it is astonishing accidents that are more devastating do not happen more frequently. Most troubling is parents with young children who put their child in danger without knowing it. Assuming a trainer is just that, someone qualified to teach, the child is handed over to incompetence. Parents need to do a little homework as well. Here is an example why it is so important to make inquiries:

I once boarded at a barn, where the owner hired his niece as a trainer; mind you, the girl could not even do a proper sitting trot or post on the correct diagonal, and would actually canter her horses through the aisles of the barn. Not too dangerous…. I could go on with stories like this, I won’t, except for one thing I still can not believe seeing; this “trainer” once changed horses by putting one foot in the stirrup of the horse she was going to ride while her other foot was in the stirrup of the horse she was dismounting. If one of these horses decided to move, she would have been a wishbone. Her qualifications for being a trainer, besides being related to someone who owned a stable, were that she watched riding videos. Duh…?

Organizations like the American Riding Instructors Association (ARIA) have courses that test trainers to a point and offer levels of qualification. ARIA is not the best qualification system and this organization still needs to be improved, but it is all we have at present. At least their trainers have some of the basics they need to teach and these qualifications represent a minimum standard of proficiency.

The Bottom Line

It is a time-consuming process of trial and error until you hit upon someone you feel safe and confident with. Beware, though, there are many frauds out there, so take your time before you settle on one trainer or another. Finding the perfect trainer is comparable to finding the ‘Missing Link’ it is an impossible task, for there are no perfect trainers or perfect horses.

I would love to hear from you about your experiences with trainers, good or bad, and hear how you dealt with a problem or how you found the ideal trainer for you

Until next time.

Quote for Today

"As he knotted the reins and took his stand, the horse's soul came into his hand, and up from the mouth that held the steel came an innermost word, half thought, half feel."

-- John Masefield

18 comments:

Callie said...

When I still had my gelding and was having some difficulty still with handling him, I brought him to a trainer suggested to me by my vet, who I respect, however, I should have had a clue when I first went to check out the barn he'd be staying at and it although it was a nice barn, the reek of amonia was so strong that it nearly knocked Steve and I over and was burning our eyes. Clue number one, I ended up pulling him out early, because he wasn't being trained....period, and they switched him to a harsh twist bit and there were a number of things. Bottom line is I had better control of this horse before he went to that trainer. When he came back, he was worse and nearly dumped me. In all of his issues, he had never done that before.

M. C. Valada said...

I feel that I've had extremely good luck with the trainers I've had and I've also seen a number of trainers who elicit the response "run away, run away."

Screaming and abusive comments are common. The use of inappropriate equipment is common. The boasting of "certificates" from high profile "horse whisperers" which have questionable value are common. The failure to wear proper attire, including helments, is rampant (there is no excuse for failing to put a helmet on a beginner and only someone who doesn't value their own brain fails to wear one as an adult, IMHO.)

Thanks for the good article. I'm looking forward to the rest.

photogchic said...

It think a good trainer always gives "kudos" to the person they learned the technique from. My trainer gives props to her educators all the time and I think that says a lot. Thank goodness you continued on with your riding even after that scary fall--yikes! Great advice.

Flying Lily said...

Excellent advice! I wasted a lot of time and money with a "trainer" who constantly dissed ALL the other trainers in the area -- which should have been a big clue.

A Bay Horse said...

I've some times wondered what I'd do if my trainer ever retired or moved. Thanks for the advice. I think I got very lucky with trainers. When I first moved to VT as a teen, I joined the local 4H club. All the kids rode with the same instructor. After college I found she was still in the business and had since advanced in dressage and continues now. She great about giving me a push to try things, but she never pushes me outside of my comfort and safety zone. The horses all seem to respect her, without her ever having to make an issue of it. Perhaps they can sense knowledge and confidence?

I've seen other trainers who yell at humans or horses at shows, and I don't think I could work with them. I think I'd get discouraged.

jesterjigger said...

These will come in handy next year, when I move! I love my current trainer, she's great at approaching a problem three different ways. Rather than just having me try the same thing over and over and over with the same result each time.

The Knutson's said...

What an informative post...good job! I was just thinking about this, because I want to take lessons again, but I do not think that I want to take them with my daughters instructor. For whatever reason, we feel uncomfortable around each other.

She is a well qualified, highly reccomended instructior, and she gets along great with my daughter, but I don't know...we just don't click.

Love your slideshow! You have a beautiful place. What kind of horse was Erik?

Grey Horse Matters said...

Knutson's,
Erik was an imported 17.2 hand imported Dutch Warmblood from Holland. Thanks for the comment.

Grey Horse Matters said...

Thanks for your comments everyone, it's interesting to hear about everybody's insights on trainers, you have known or worked with.

billie said...

Arlene, what a great post.

We have been pretty fortunate in our trainers, although we seem to have topped out with each of them in one way or another and moved on. Right now my daughter is working with an upper level dressage trainer who has a schoolmaster that fits daughter (ie 15h instead of 16-17h) and it's been a pleasure to see the work they're doing.

This isn't going to address the issue of teaching Cody the ropes or getting the pony further in his comfort with jumping, but for now, it's what my daughter wants to do.

I'm actually between trainers, and feeling like I need to make some decisions in the next month or so about what I want to do next.

We're on the list to host a Mark Rashid clinic in 2009 but that's about it!

Grey Horse Matters said...

Billie,
I'm glad your daughter has found a trainer she likes. It really is hard to find someone you click with and respect.
Hosting a Mark Rashid clinic in '09, I'd like to take a trip down for that!

otterkat said...

Thanks A, that's really interesting and lots of great advice. I like your "How To" articles / posts SO much, they're so informative and as an adult re-learner you've given me loads of valuable insights into the horsey world that I'd otherwise be pretty clueless about. Fabulous resource.
- jules

deejbrown said...

This information is desperately needed to avoid injury, including the chronic fear & intimidation than can be instilled by the wrong instructor/training. You are spot on to issues of safety and one's ability to learn in a supportive environment. Thanks!

Nuzzling Muzzles said...

I do remember reading this post, but wasn't having problems with my trainer at the time. Thanks for suggesting I read it again.

Grey Horse Matters said...

Nuz Muz,
I hope it can help you a little with your trainer/training.

Anonymous said...

LIFE IS ABOUT LEARNING, RIGHT?? BOY , DID I LEARN ALOT WHEN I STARTED TAKING RIDING LESSONS AT A LOCAL BARN. MY EXPERIENCE BEFORE THIS POINT CONSISTED OF TRAIL RIDES AND A HANDFUL OF LESSONS. THIS BARN WAS A FRIEND OF MINES FRIEND, SO I DIDN'T FEEL COMFORTABLE ASKING TOO MANY QUESTIONS (RED FLAG #1). THE GIRL GIVING THE LESSON WAS HALF MY AGE (IM 41 , SHE WAS 20; RED FLAG #2).I FOUND OUT LATER THAT SHE GAVE LESSONS TO HELP PAY FOR BOARD FOR HER 2 HORSES. ANYWAY, INSTEAD OF TAKING ME OUT ON THE RELIABLE , OLD , SCHOOL HORSE; SHE PUT ME ON A TRAIL HORSE FOR ADVANCED RIDERS ,ONLY. I , OF COURSE , DID NOT KNOW THIS AT THE TIME. I DON'T REMEMBER WHAT HAPPENED EXACTLY,DUE TO A CONCUSSION, BUT APPARENTLY HE WAS BARN SOUR AND TURNED QUICKLY DURING A TROT. I FELL AND BROKE MY R FOREARM. I HAD TO HAVE SURGERY TO FIX IT AND NOW I HAVE PLATES AND BOLTS IN MY ARM. THERE ARE MANY MORALS TO THIS STORY: FIRST, ASK QUESTIONS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, MAKE SURE THE TRAINER IS CERTIFIED!! SINCE MY ACCIDENT , THE BARN HAS SINCE CLOSED DOWN (SHERRIFF SALE) .2ND:TAKE THINGS SLOW! I WAS BEGINNING TO GET COCKY AND THINK THAT I HAD IT ALL TOGETHER, I HAVE LEARNED A GREAT DEAL OF RESPECT FOR THESE POWERFUL,BEAUTIFUL ANIMALS. WHILE I AM COMPLETELY RECOVERED PHYSICALLY, MENTALLY I AM CONFLICTED BETWEEN WANTING TO TRY AGAIN AND JUST BEING SCARED.
ANY ADVICE?

Grey Horse Matters said...

Hi Anonymous,
Sorry to hear about your injury and your bad experience. I will get back to your question shortly so check back in a few hours.Thanks for commenting.

Grey Horse Matters said...

Dear Anon – I’m sorry you had such a negative experience with your ‘trainer.’ Sadly, stories like yours are all too common. Asking questions is the most important thing a prospective student can do, but knowing which questions to ask – and whether you can believe the answers – is not so easy! There are a lot of self-professed experts out there who are better at marketing themselves than they are at training horses and/or riders. Knowing the difference, as most of us find out the hard way, can be a serious matter.

You are understandable wary, and you should take your time and really do your homework before scheduling another lesson. There are good, safe instructors out there, you just have to know how to spot them. My advice? Don’t be afraid to quiz your prospective instructor before you even schedule a lesson. Ask about the horse you will ride, his age, experience, issues, problems other riders may have had with him, etc. Ask for credentials: More important than WHO someone trained with is what they got out of that experience and whether they learned enough and have the personality to teach others. Ask the instructor to explain their philosophy and method to you – if they can’t or won’t, this is a red flag. Have them explain their goals for your riding and how they plan to achieve them, for example, what skills do they plan on teaching first and why? You want to know your instructor has a plan and knows how to develop a rider from the beginning stages.

It’s important to recognize that not everyone who rides is qualified to also teach – teaching requires a separate set of skills, and a lot of good riders are not good instructors; the biggest red flag is any trainer who becomes impatient, who evades your questions or who simply can’t answer them. Then go and watch some lessons. See the horses in action. Really get a feel for the trainer’s style; her interaction with the student; how the students respond; see the kind of horse you will ride and how it behaves, and get a real feeling for whether you will be comfortable with all of this. If anything bothers you, trust your instincts, and keep looking. But once you find someone you feel comfortable with, who will answer your questions and take the time to help you understand and to feel secure, you will have a much safer and more positive experience. Hope this helps. Best of luck to you!